Recently, 2 Chinese Survival Shows named Me To Us(我们的乐队) and Youth With You (2020)(青春有你第二季) are about to release, therefore, I’m going to compare these 2 similar shows in 5 aspects for you to judge which show would win.
|Program Name||Me To Us(我们的乐队)|| Youth With You (2020) |
|Type of the Show||Survival Band Show||Survival Girl Group Show|
|Premiere Time||Mar. 14||Mar. 12|
|Broadcasting Platform||Mango TV， Jiangsu Satellite TV||Tencent Video|
|Broadcasting Time||Every Sat. at 22:30( Jiangsu Satellite TV) and at 22:35(Mango TV)||Every Thur. and Sat. at 8:00pm|
|Mentors||Nicholas Tse Ting-Fung(谢霆锋), Jam Hsiao(萧敬腾), Wang Junkai(王俊凯)||Cai Xukun(蔡徐坤)， Lisa， Ella Chen(陈嘉桦)， Jony J|
|Similar TV Show||Super Band||Produce 101|
|Weibo Official Site||@Me To Us-Band Infinity Company (@我们的乐队-乐队无限公司) 95k Followers||@IQYI Youth With You (@爱奇艺青春有你) 847k Followers|
Round 1: The Mentors
Now that we have come to round 1: the competition of the regular members of each TV Programme. Firstly let’s have a look at what “Me to Us has” for mentors:
1. Me To Us Mentor: Nicholas Tse Ting-Fung(谢霆锋)
Tse is a multi-talented celebrity from Hong Kong, he initially entered the entertainment industry in 1996 as a singer and made his film debut in 1998. He’s also a successful martial artist, songwriter, entrepreneur, and chef.
- Hong Kong Film Award for Best New Performer 1999
- Hundred Flowers Award for Best Supporting Actor 2006
- Hong Kong Film Award for Best Supporting Actor 2010
- Asian Film Award for Best Supporting Actor 2010
- Hong Kong Film Award for Best Actor 2011
- Forbes China Celebrity 100 top 10 2015
2. Me To Us Mentor: Jam Hsiao(萧敬腾)
- Top 10 Songs of the Year and Best New Artist at HITO Radio Music Awards 2009
- Songs of the Year, Male Singer and Asia Popular Idol at Metro Radio Mandarin Music Awards 2010
- The Hong Kong Film Award for Best New Performer 2012;
- Best Male Singer (HK, Macau, Taiwan regions) at 11th CCTV-MTV Awards 2012
- Best Male Vocalist at 24th Golden Melody Awards 2013
3. Me To Us Mentor: Wang Junkai(王俊凯)
- Guinness World Record of Most forwarded Weibo post-2015
- Top Ten Songs at Fresh Asia Chart Festival 2016 and 2017
- Generation Breakthrough Award at L’Officiel Night 2018
- Newcomer Award at 17th Golden Phoenix Awards 2019
- Fashion Figure of the Year and Most Commercially Valuable Artist at 16th Esquire Man At His Best Awards 2019
- Popular Artist of the Year at Weibo Awards Ceremony 2020
4. Youth With You Producer: Cai Xukun(蔡徐坤)
- Newcomer Of The Year at GQ Men Of The Year Awards 2018;
- Annual Idol Youth Award at Cosmo Beauty Ceremony 2018;
- Melody Award and RBT Singer of The Year at Migu Music Awards 2018；
- Annual Male Artist Popularity Award and Peak Artist of the Year at Sogou IN 2018;
- Popular Male Artist of The Year at Sohu Fashion Awards 2018;
- Popular Newcomer Won at 2018 Weibo Variety Awards;
- Annual Artist with the Most Commercial Value at 1st SIR Movie Culture and Entertainment Conference 2018;
- Annual Headline Icon Of The Year and Today’s Headline Idol of the Year at Today’s Headlines Annual Ceremony 2018;
- Baidu Encyclopedia Most Artist’s Fan Power Award Won 
- New Power Character of the Year and Music Star of the Year at Tencent Entertainment White Paper 2018;
- Outstanding Youth Leader and Goodwill Ambassador of China – Jamaica of People’s Republic of China 2019;
- Most Popular Male Singer and Top Ten Golden Songs of The Year at Chinese Top 10 Music Awards 2019;
- Most Influential Idol of the Year at Fresh Asia Music Awards 2019;
- All-Rounded Star of the Year iQiyi All-Star Carnival 2019;
- Marketable Artist of the Year Tencent Video All-Star Awards 2019;
- Most Popular Musician of the Year at Weibo Awards Ceremony 2020…
5. Youth With You Mentor: Lisa
- Person of the Year at The Standard in both 2018 and 2019
6. Youth With You Mentor: Ella Chen(陈嘉桦)
- Yakushi Pearl Award 2016
7. Youth With You Mentor: Jony J
Jony J is a Chinese rapper, he attended The Rap of China Season 1 and got the 4th place.
- The most popular rapper at China hip hop award ceremony 2017
Round 1: Conclusion
Copartners of Me To Us Nicholas Tse, Jam Hsiao, and Wang Jun Kai have all been China’s top stars for many years, as a result, they must have a strong social influence and marketing might.
Except for Ella Chen, the other three mentors of Youth With You (2020) Cai Xukun, Lisa, and Jony J are only notable in China in recent years, so their influence might not that much compare to Me To Us’ Copartners. But we have to wait and see.
Round 2: The Band VS The Idol Girl Group
Before the keyboard was developed, the most common band was the four-piece band which is composed of a lead guitarist and a rhythm guitarist (with one of them singing lead vocals), a bassist, and a drummer, another common formation is the trio: a vocalist, electric guitarist, bass guitarist, and a drummer. All these artists join as a group to provide all of the musical elements which are vocals, chords, bass lines, and drumming.
In the TV Show Me To Us, all contestants were divided into 7 groups according to their profession. Before the competition, some of them were selected as the ACE members because of their achievements, they might be the leader of a band, several members don’t think it a good idea because in their opinion all band members should be equal, but its the rule and ACE members can also be replaced.
17 Vocalists in Me To Us with 3 ACE members
10 Guitarists in Me To Us with 3 ACE members
10 Bass Guitarists in Me To Us with no ACE members
9 Drummers in Me To Us with 2 ACE members
9 Keyboards Players in Me To Us with 4 ACE members
10 Special Instruments Players in Me To Us with no ACE members
3 All-rounded Producers in Me To Us who are all ACE members
The Idol Girl Group
A band member in Me To Us can be very professional in only one specific field, while to be an idol girl group member in Youth With You (2020), you will be judged in various ways and according to your comprehensive ability, you will be divided into A, B, C, D and F, five groups.
Are you good looking? Gorgeous? Beautiful? Cool? Cute? Whatever you look, you should have your own style and be attractive.
Popularity is not everything, but it does mean something. The below 9 girls have the most Weibo followers on Weibo.
If you don’t have talent, you cannot ignite the stage, for instance, this talent could be dancing, singing, rapping, and other special talents.
Round 3: Publicity
Good advance publicity could help audiences know more about the show and its also a fundamental factor to make it popular. For this reason, I made this infographic for you to have a better understanding of their work.
Round 4: ACE Members
9 Most Popular Trainees of Youth With You (2020)
According to various statistics, the above photos of 9 girls are the most popular ones out of 109 trainees before the premiere of the Youth With You Season 2. Each of them has her own ability to catch people’s eyes, but popularity is not the only standard, let’s see who will shine your eyes and who will make the debut at the end.
15 ACE Members of Me To Us
There are 15 ACE members in Me To Us, they are 3 vocalists, 3 guitarists, 3 all-rounded producers, 4 keyboards players, and 2 drummers. Do you wonder why these 15 members are selected to be the ACE members? I want to know that too, let’s watch the show to find out. But what will be more attractive for me is when someone is plucked from obscurity and become glamorous.
Round 5: Stage Design
The style of these 2 stages are quite different, one is shinny while another is cool. Which one do you prefer?
I compared Me To Us and Youth With You Season 2 in 5 aspects, both of these 2 TV reality shows will be released very soon, which one will you watch? Above all, I hope you will find more pleasure in watching these 2 TV variety shows.
In the end, let’s have a vote: which show would you think to have a higher audience rating?